Abigail Ann McCarthy, PA-C

Abigail Ann McCarthy, PA-C

Physician Assistant

Primary Contact

315-833-9900

Services & Specialties

Areas of Specialization

  • Physician Assistant

Locations & Contact

Conditions Treated

  • Nephrology

Education & Certifications

Board Certifications

Physician Assistants, National Commission on Certification of

Provider Ratings

The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy. Learn More >

4.9 out of 5

(214 ratings)

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.

103 Reviews

06/03/2026

Excellent very caring 👏

06/01/2026

It's a pleasure having Abigail as a provider.

05/27/2026

Keep that girl, she is great.

05/26/2026

ABIGAIL MCCarthy is thorough ,kind and patient with my daughter. Thank you.

05/18/2026

Very informative

05/14/2026

Abby was very interested in finding the cause of my health issue while treating me with respect

05/13/2026

Very compassionate, understanding, sympathetic to my problems. Treated me as an actual person, not just a patient with an illness.

05/11/2026

Dr McCarthy has a great personality..she is very warm and inviting...and very knowledgeable

05/08/2026

Abby is amazing very caring bout my health and well being

05/05/2026

If she was out of network I would follow her and that means alot.

05/04/2026

Very down to earth, personable, interested in her patients well being. She is an asset to the St. Joseph’s Team. Would highly recommend her to others.

04/30/2026

She was very nice and professional

04/30/2026

Keep up the professional work

04/29/2026

Proactive, knowledgeable and thorough

04/27/2026

Excellent provider, would recommend her to all

04/27/2026

Abby is always is willing to offer recommendations when I've seen her my health concerns. This visit was in preparation for possible surgery. She explained what I could expect and why I would be a good candidate. I was able to get an appointment at the right time and she spent a generous amount of time with me.

04/27/2026

Always a pleasure to see Abby!

04/24/2026

She listens and cares the best Dr I've EVER had

04/16/2026

Abigail was a pleasure to deal with.

04/16/2026

Compassionate, relatable to my age

04/15/2026

Abigail was very professional and pleasant. She asked the proper questions and provided excellent explanations and planned follow-up actions. She also went out of her way to get copies of my health information from another provider.

04/08/2026

Abigail is a very positive member of St. Joseph’s Healthcare and is compassionate to her patients and treats them with respect.

04/03/2026

She is THE best doctor I’ve ever had. I’ve been going through something for 6 years and she is the only one out of MANY to schedule many tests and take action into truly trying to figure it out! She is very admirable, kind, sweet, funny, and extremely knowledgeable. If the rest of my family had a certain insurance they would be going to her.

03/24/2026

👍

03/06/2026

Abby is one of the best physicians I’ve had in years! She listens and she is just so pleasant to talk to.

02/23/2026

She genuinely cares and listens

02/17/2026

I really like this provider. She really listens to the patient and she's really good about giving me complete information about meds, tests etc. She's also kind and compassionate.

02/17/2026

Abby is a warm caring individual that listened and recommended good care

02/16/2026

Abigail Mccarthy takes the time to listen before she makes any decisions and never feel rushed during my appointments. She is very knowledgeable and thorough. I appreciate how she clearly explains medical information. She is truly dedicated to her patients well-being. I strongly recommend Abigail Mccarthy as a provider.

02/05/2026

vey good bed side manners. Good listener and caring. same with nurse Kelsey D.

02/03/2026

Very responsive and willing to provide recommendations and direction.

02/03/2026

Abigail is an excellent PA - she takes time to listen to the patient’s concerns and takes the appropriate time to get the situation resolved, while always being compassionate.

01/28/2026

Extremely lucky to have her. Thank you!

01/26/2026

Abbey is a very kind, caring provider. I love that she is always willing to help and listens to all of my concerns. I never feel rushed with her.

01/23/2026

Professional and engaged with patient health issues and details

01/20/2026

Very nice and official PA and knowledgeable

01/16/2026

Abigail is very compassionate and listens to my concerns. I’m so happy to have found this group!

01/09/2026

Very nice, knowledgeable, helpful & caring.

01/08/2026

Respectful, professional and answered all questions asked.

01/08/2026

Es muy amable, y y estubo muy sonriente, y trasmite seguridad cuando hablo conmigo.

01/08/2026

NO COMPLAINTS, SHE TRIED TO DO HER BEST FOR ME.

12/26/2025

She's amazing, considerate and caring

12/24/2025

She is very nice

12/23/2025

Abby is WONDERFUL. I am extremely comfortable talking about anything medical with her. I’d recommend her to anyone!

12/20/2025

Very professional and friendly.

12/05/2025

I am so happy I was able to see Dr. McCarthy. I feel like I finally have a plan for my health and that I can talk with her about anything in a judgement free zone.

12/04/2025

Easy to talk to. Can deal with what she needs to.

12/03/2025

I have come to trust Abigail and feel fortunate that she is available when needed most. Both Kelsey, the nurse, Abigail, and the man who drew my blood, made my visit a good experience. In addition, Abigail is highly supportive and I am comforted with her common sense approach.

11/25/2025

As we receive the information you gave to us as you examined us, and talked with us, we fel you are our friend.Thank you.

11/21/2025

She did great. I feel comfortable with her. Because of her my life is starting to get back on track. I feel much more functional day to day.

11/18/2025

Abby is professional and listens and explains well and answers my questions so I fully understand.

11/18/2025

Excellent PA!

11/17/2025

She was great. Very professional. And answered all my questions. Easy to talk to

11/12/2025

She is a boss queen! Knows what she is doing and really helps you get referrals who accept Medicaid.

11/05/2025

Excellent and thorough

10/31/2025

Great

10/29/2025

I am really lucky to have found Abigail, she is knowledgeable and respectful. Excellent relationship and very professional.

10/29/2025

Anxious to visit with her again!

10/24/2025

Thank you Abigail for sharing your expert opinion, helping my issues.

10/24/2025

She's wonderful 🙌‼️

10/22/2025

She's very nice and takes time

10/22/2025

She made me feel hers. I finally feel hopefully again and am glad I found Abigale. I’m comfortable with her and I believe she will change my life for the better.

10/22/2025

Does a complete exam, follow up, lab work and communication is always open and complete.

10/21/2025

She was present and attentive as well explaining if she needed to type and or refer to something. It was a great visit and quite enjoyable.

10/14/2025

Very good

10/10/2025

Professional, cooperative, pleasant to deal with.

10/09/2025

You’re the best, thank you!!

10/09/2025

Such a happy positive professional

10/09/2025

My first visit with Abigail McCarthy was excellent! She was thorough, and so nice.

10/08/2025

A very positive visit. Kind understanding and she listened to my concerns

10/07/2025

She was very helpful and friendly.

10/06/2025

I’m so happy to have Abby as my primary, you can tell she cares about her patients

10/03/2025

Abby was very personal, knowledgeable and put my mind at ease about my health concerns immediately.

09/30/2025

I think she is a very good Doctor and her attitude and attention to my physical condition was impeccable

09/30/2025

Thanks for great care!

09/29/2025

I am glad I found this practice

09/25/2025

I was glad that she had sent me for a x-ray on my knee.

09/25/2025

The Best!

09/23/2025

I am a new patient and so glad I landed in Abigail’s hands.

09/19/2025

She is excellent.

09/19/2025

Great

09/18/2025

She is amazing, caring and takes the time to genuinely " hear " you the best dr I've had hands down

09/16/2025

AWESOME

09/15/2025

I felt that Abigail understood my problem and to was willing to help.

09/12/2025

It's refreshing to see someone who loves their job as much as she does, and cares about the patients too. I know my daughter will feel very comfortable going to Abigail.

09/11/2025

She was Awsome!

09/11/2025

PA Abigail McCarthy was very friendly and made you feel welcome. She listens to your concerns, she was honest and straightforward.

09/05/2025

She was great, very knowledgeable and put me at ease…

09/03/2025

She always takes time to listen to my questions and concerns. She is very caring and supportive and I don’t leave having questions

08/27/2025

Good office.

08/27/2025

Abigal McCarthy was very friendly and helpful.

08/26/2025

Well done, thank you.

08/21/2025

She's very personable! She's great!

08/18/2025

She addressed all of my concerns and did not rush me out

08/13/2025

She is professional, shows concern, listens to questions and gives me answers in a way to make sure I understand.

08/13/2025

Very very nice and knowledgeable. And very helpful.

07/24/2025

Outstanding

07/21/2025

She was great. Very attentive and made me feel so comfortable

07/16/2025

She was very nice and I would recommend her to my friends and family

07/15/2025

Abigail McCarthy spent a good amount of time with me and we discussed a lot of things. I feel like she was attentive and heard me.

07/15/2025

Very caring about my medical problem. Gave me instructions to follow and recommended I follow up if I wasn't feeling better with my hand/finger. She even has me go for xray prior to appointment since the injury occurred on a weekend. She didn't want to delay proper care.

07/14/2025

Abby was very caring and patient which is exactly what I was looking for!

07/10/2025

Abigail McCRthy is an invaluable asset to Dr McMahon’s practice. I am so grateful that this practice accepted me as a patient.
Show more